UPDATE: Why Baseball Players Win and Football Players Lose. Update

“Brady Wins, Why I Was Wrong” was posted today.
I posted <a href=”http://clarkgriffithblog/2015/08/27″>Here</a&gt; and article on why Brady will lose his arbitration and why baseball players win theirs. Powerlineblog.com was kind to post it in their picks section and Paul Mirengoff added this comment.


Clark Griffith explains why he thinks “Tom Brady will lose and baseball players win.” It’s because “in Major League Baseball, grievances are heard and decided by an impartial arbitrator. In the National Football League, the person who hears and decides grievances is the commissioner.”

I want to focus on a more general question: Why has the Major League Baseball Players Association consistently negotiated more favorable contracts on a full range of issues than its counterpart, the National Football Players Association? One explanation, which comes through in Clark’s piece, is that the baseball players hired smarter people early on.

I don’t dispute this. However, I have a more general theory: baseball players are more ornery than football players (and, for that matter, basketball players).

Football and basketball stars become heroes at an early age. They are worshiped in high school (and sometimes before), courted extravagantly by college recruiters, pampered in college, and then (if they’re good enough) placed directly into the luxurious life of the big leagues. (To be fair, though,a great many come from poor or lower middle class backgrounds.)

Baseball players are less celebrated in high school and college (if they attend). And they almost always enter the profession via the minor leagues, where they typically spend several years (quite possibly five or more if they become professionals right out of high school).

The minor leagues are a grinding, humbling experience. The pay is low, the towns lack glamour, and the bus rides are long, tedious, and not very comfortable.

Thus, my theory goes, when baseball players finally make it, they have a fortitude that their more spoiled counterparts in football and basketball lack. That’s why they are more likely to hang tough in negotiations, as they did most famously during the 1994 labor dispute when the baseball season was lost.

I learned from my father, a labor organizer, that ultimately union leaders are only as tough as they can persuade their members to be. I believe that, at least until now, the leaders of the baseball union have found it easier than their counterparts in other sports to persuade their members, most of whom come up the hard way, to be tough.

What Mirengoff says about baseball player toughness is true. As batters they stand against nine opponents alone, to face the pitcher.  This toughness in play is also toughness in negotiations and I have negotiated deals with players and they don’t quit.

I attribute this to the games them selves. Football players are taught from the first day to act as a unit and obey the coach. When the whistle blows, they do push ups.  Not so baseball players who play the most grueling schedule of 162 games, that test physical and mental toughness. They lose 40% of the games if they’re good, are put out 70% of the time if they are good hitters. They play, pitch and field as individuals, alone. Read <a href:”https://clarkgriffithblog.com/2013/03/13&#8243;.>Baseballs-timeless-appeal</a.

We can’t forget about the owners. The NFL is a true partnership. They have to stand together. Not so baseball owners who, historically, have found the top 1/3 in market size doing all they can do to crush the bottom 2/3. Having a bad labor deal, helped this plan.

With all this in mind, if the baseball players had hired Ed Garvey and the football players had hired Marvin Miller and his lawyer, Dick Moss, the positions of the unions would be reversed.  Talent is talent, especially in the major leagues.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s